Well, trying to watch it. It is supposedly based on a Mark Millar comic, so maybe there’s something of value in here, but also they fired the showrunner partway thru and replaced him with a new guy, so clearly visions differ. Doing this live-action is stupid; it looks goofy at best, the CGI and greenscreens are hilariously ineffectual, the shitty color grading makes everything look like mud indoors or at “night” (all obviously shot day-for-night but then darkened digitally), it would be so much better as a cartoon. It makes CW superhero shows look competent.
At the start, there’s preachy old-school Justice League ripoffs, with a “Code” of no killing, no leading, no going into politics. Which we know is nonsense, it doesn’t work, because that much power in Human(-ish) hands corrupts absolutely. They claim the “new supervillains” are “going crazy” by killing, instead of just harmless bank robbery, but we see mundane bank robbers gunning people down at the start, so there’s nothing new or supervillainy about it. Utopian, asshole Superman father, chastises his son Paragon for killing a supervillain who had just killed two heroes, and however many more in his inevitable escape from prison. Completely stiff, uncompromising, Christian supremacist. But I do not believe for a second that someone can be like that for 100 years without loosening up or becoming completely corrupt, so the whole premise is a fail so far.
The mother’s also a superhero, but fairly ineffectual, she’s like Edith Bunker with even less of a spine to stand up to her asshole husband (who, admittedly, could pull her spine out if she did more than talk back). The son’s a whipped dog who does what daddy says. There’s a mostly-absent daughter who doesn’t pretend to fight “crime”; she’s chased off when she does show up. The telepath uncle is maybe the only likeable character in the first few episodes.
Long sections are set in the 1920s, at the start of the Depression, and the father’s origin as an asshole; but they seem so far to be completely irrelevant, a few throwaway lines would’ve told us as much.
The power sets are ridiculously cartoony. Most can fly just by wishing at the sky, Utopian has laser beam eyes of course, a few others have weak pew-pew-pew energy powers. They all seem to be made of steel, but the fighting sets don’t reflect that, a couple bits of fake marble break but the bad CGI grass doesn’t even dent when a superhero is smashed into it at mach speed. Zero effort on detail and realism.
Invincible, despite being a cartoon with intentionally cartoony physics including throwing baseballs around the planet at something like 1% light speed and then fighting aliens coming thru portals, is both physically and psychologically more realistic.
Now I’m down to fast-forwarding over anything with the family, unless Uncle Walt’s involved.
Oh, finally end of E2/start of E3 we get to see some origin story, where the rich (or ex-rich, as Depression starts) get superpowers, the poor don’t even get a pension. George in the 1920s story, and his son Hutch and his little gang of petty near-supers in the present, greatly improve the show. Like, this is an entirely different and better show when they’re on screen, than the whiny, horrible Utopian family.
★★☆☆☆ with the Utopians on screen, ★★★½☆ with Hutch. Maybe the show will average out to ★★★☆☆.