Wizards Address the Orc Problem

Nice to see this directly addressed. Obviously I still prefer my solution which was just to replace Orcs with a more sympathetic species, but WotC is a business with tight margins so they’ll just do the minimum necessary to not be running a minstrel show.

I’ve never really used “Drow” except in the GDQ modules (Giants went great, never got a party to finish Drow, let alone Queen of the Demonweb Pits), I preferred the Sidhe from Celtic myth making all “Elves” pretty, alien, and sociopathic (interesting point, there’s a subworld of Queen, “Caer Sidi”, which inspired me to get into Elves-as-Sidhe!), and later the Gazetteer Shadow Elves created underground Elves with a grudge, but they’re not Drow. Having the black-skinned, white-haired Elves be “evil” and relentlessly, cartoonishly cruel torturers, poisoners, perverts, and backstabbers wasn’t one of TSR’s better takes. And then R.A. Salvatore, the third-worst writer in the world (I’ve read two of his books, part-way, and they’re so bad it’s impossible to finish them), made his Mary Sue character Drizzle-doo-wah-Diddy who’s the One Good Drow, which became TSR canon. I’d flush the entire archetype, I don’t think it’s fixable.

The Vistani thing is also pretty hard to fix. They’re stereotype “Gypsies”. You can pull elements out to make carny folk, maybe, but if you have a tribe of thieves and soothsayers in a caravan it’s obvious what you’re doing. There’s also Romani-based caricatures in Greyhawk, and who knows where else, it was a very popular trope with the ’80s-’90s TSR writers, because “a Gypsy tells you your fortune” is a super easy plot hook, if you’re unaware/unconcerned about your racism.

Changing ability score modifiers is weird. Now, there’s no modifiers in Original D&D, everyone has the same 3d6 scores down the line, and fairly simple species special abilities and some harsh class limits. AD&D 1st Ed added the racist & sexist race vs stat & class tables, and each following edition dug in further. Hm, looking at my AD&D PDF (bought back when Paizo had the rights), I could swear in the original print back in ’79 there was a Human column up front there, that’s been redacted, where Human females got 3/17 Strength and probably Constitution & Charisma (being used more for leadership in AD&D, and women leaders were Not A Thing to those guys). Was this changed in a later printing? And the Half-Orcs got seriously shafted here.

Note this is the AD&D 1st ed text on Half-Orcs. “Orcs are fecund”, “player characters which are of the half-orc race are within the superior 10%”. What the fuck, Gary?

I don’t really have any use for D&D 5th Ed, it’s a cartoony game with 10-100x as many rules as it needs, and they’ve dug themselves into this hole by pushing out old content which was noted as being problematic 20 years ago, but at least WotC’s a little self-aware of the things they’re publishing now.

What I’m Watching: Doom Patrol

So back in 1989, Grant Morrison took over Doom Patrol, which had been around in various forms since 1963, the original genius in a wheelchair, deranged freak “students”, fighting weird enemies and society, months before the X-Men. Except instead of having white kids (and later token Storm & Jubilee) stand in for racism with a trite ending every time; Doom Patrol had broken people stand up for themselves, insane, crippled, or just weird as they are. Grant took a weird thing and made it weirder, with increasingly postmodern, deranged plots and villains that just make no sense, cut-up stories and art. Great comic, everyone should read it. Don’t bother with anything Grant didn’t write.

The show on HoboMax does a decent job of making a core Doom Patrol team: Larry/Negative Being (but not gender-changed Rebis yet?), Cliff/Robotman (voice-acted by Brendan Fraser), Jane/Crazy Jane, Rita/Elasti-Girl, Niles/Chief, and Vic/Cyborg. Larry’s easy, a body-wrap of gauze and a shitty ball lightning effect; he whines about his wife and boyfriend a lot, nobody cares. Cliff has a fairly good whole-body suit, and we see a few flashbacks to frumpy Fraser when he had a body. Jane gets a bunch of additional voice actresses for the alternates, her powers are mostly shitty jump-cut teleports and such, the only impressive power is speaking words into steel floating in the air, which become knives. Rita’s a pretty good special effect, instead of growing and stretching, she just turns into The Blob but made of fat tissue, oozes into or over everything, and her character trying to fight what a horrible thing she is, is well-portrayed.

Chief, I haven’t seen a lot of yet, he’s a pompous, secret-filled, treacherous jackass who’ll do anything to “put things right” but also to work on his Human experiments; it’s Timothy Dalton, so he may be able to pull it off. Mr Nobody, the main villain, is Alan Tudyk, and he gets some CGI erasure to be half-there, which is fine, he mostly just chews scenery and taunts people, nothing actually happens.

The problem here is Vic, fucking Cyborg. In the old Teen Titans comics, Cyborg was the joyless stick-up-his-ass bureaucrat part of the team, but he was opposed by the far more competent Robin/Nightwing, and Beast Boy and every other crazy vigilante to shout him down. Put in with the Doom Patrol, they’re no more respectful of Vic the Dick, but he’s the least crazy and so kind of runs roughshod over them. Someone please dump him in a recycling bin. Every scene Vic is in is just a drag.

I’m kind of impressed they mostly stuck with ’80s-style practical effects and lowest of low-budget surface CGI/painting on the film effects. There’s nothing here they couldn’t have done back in the ’80s.

Speaking of, there’s a… setting trick. So, Doom Patrol is deeply tied up in WWII mad scientists, and it’s written, set in the ’80s. But this show is set in the present. They just skip 30 years, assert that everyone stayed in the mansion and didn’t age. I don’t know if this will ever be addressed for how dumb it is, but whatever, it lets them have the original crew & villains somehow in 2020. Don’t think about it too hard, I guess.

The plots are gibberish. There’s a hole in the ground that eats a lame town, and then they travel into a donkey, in order to spit the town back out. They travel to Paraguay and watch a puppet show, put on by living puppets. They’re certainly trying to be as weird as Doom Patrol, it’s fairly pointless so far, but I’m amused for the most part. It could use some editing to get the pacing up (easy: Just delete every scene Vic is in), these 44-minute episodes feel 2 hours long.

★★★½☆

What I’m Playing: Romancing SaGa Re;univerSe (Saga RS)

Yet another gachapon game based on a classic GameBoy and later Square Enix franchise (SaGa Frontier, etc). To a large extent, this is as basic, standard, zero innovation of a gacha phone game as I’ve ever seen.

The characters are very pretty, there’s some great character art, and then it goes into 16-bit sprite art for the game. Nice retro tone. Repetitive music’s getting a little annoying, but it has sliders for BGM, SFX, and voice, unlike so many other games.

Gameplay has a 5-character party, with various formations possible, and turn-based combat, with increasingly powerful skills, multi-character combos, and passives; it’s not a real “FIGHT CAST ITEM DODGE FLEE” menu, so all your tactical choices really are in party setup. Right now my main party only has a few melee fighters and one caster, and I just summoned an S rank healer, just need a better AOE caster. I keep trying to use Sif as a main DPS, her stats & damage are amazing… and she dies in every hard fight despite having high HP, I don’t know why. I’ve tried moving her position, giving her best armor, nothing works.

There’s a weird distinction in this between characters and “styles” who are the specific instances by rank (A, S, SS, like Lake Woebegone everyone’s children are above average, there’s no N or lower ranks, no trash chars but A’s aren’t really useful). You don’t gain experience instantly, you have to return to town, hit Dojo, and level up. And increasing level cap/rank is possible, but it costs a lot of gold and “character parts”.

There’s a shop with random gear and character parts, and will be a forge but I haven’t unlocked it yet.

This could be any gacha game—if I really cared, I’d play more Another Eden, Last Cloudia, or get back into DanMachi now there’s been new episodes—but it’s competently done, I’m having fun grinding these chars up for the moment, and advancing a quest where some Robin-like waif is looking for his sister in “Graves”, giant dungeon towers that appear across the land every 300 years.

I don’t know if Squenix is going to make any money out of me, there’s so far been no paywall where I needed more gems, so it’s just a free game.

What I’m Watching: Adventure Time: Distant Lands: BMO

Available on the HoboMax.

BMO, especially delusional BMO being a hero, is generally my favorite character of AT, even tho I skip all those awful Grables eps. So I was looking forward to this. Not happy about the result.

No way to talk about this without spoilers:












BMO and their potatoes are going to Mars. But then they’re redirected to an ancient space station made of little environment pods, like blown-up Xandar (in the comics, not the boring planet in the Guardians movies), or Robert Heinlein’s Orphans of the Sky, and BMO sets off to save everyone!

Unfortunately everyone in the station sucks. The bunny kid sidekick is useless, spineless, and nigh-treacherous (but too spineless to be an effective traitor), the repair drone is just a follower, the adults are all villains or parasites who should be broken down for scrap. The character designs, other than a few sight gag characters in street scenes, are very plain, either blobs, the laziest-drawn humanoid bunnies ever, or a few alien/elf hybrids. Literally the only sympathetic characters in the entire show, besides BMO, are two thieving bugs, and a scrap robot (voiced by Simone Giertz! So there’s like one good thing about this!)

There’s an amazing environment, a setup perfect for a long series, which is wasted on a very stupid plot and a trite non-Adventure Time ending. Brute force or reason shouldn’t get you out of trouble in AT, only insanity, lateral thinking, or coincidence should. Pen Ward hasn’t written or directed since S8, everyone still involved is like 3rd-hand hires from when it was good, so tone drifting towards Hollywood garbage writing is inevitable, but tragic.

Well. That was, I guess not surprising after S10, but disappointing. Will any further eps be better?

★★☆☆☆

What I’m Watching: Adventure Time

HoboMax has Adventure Time, and soon to have some spinoff specials “Distant Lands”, so I watched seasons 8-10 which I hadn’t previously seen, and I’m now rewatching 6-7 which I apparently don’t remember at all. Who needs linear time?

  • Season 8: Mostly episodic, often great adventure episodes. This is what I liked the show for originally. “I Am a Sword” seems to be adventure, but then introduces a real tragedy, which turns into the Fern sub-plot for the next 2 seasons. “Preboot” and “Reboot” activate Susan’s origin story, and “The Invitation” starts a very long 8-part story about the last of the Humans; individual parts of this were good, but continuity is annoying in a show like this. 11-minute episodes are perfect for delivering the science-fantasy parody, 2-parters are a little long, 8 is (if you’ll forgive the ’80s sitcom reference) enough.

  • Season 9: Immediately starts with another 8-part quest about elemental (Candy, Slime, Ice, Fire) corruption. While I like Ice King/Simon and Weird Lady/Betty in small doses, an entire series about two amnesiac obsessives is excruciating. Since all the elemental princesses and inhabitants are reduced to insanity, there’s really only Jake & Finn to have any sane dialog, and Jake’s just a dog. The last few eps resolve Finn & his weird grass clone.

  • Season 10: Almost all of these were terrible. “The First Investigation” was good, a nice self-contained story. “Jake the Starchild” and “Temple of Mars” are decent science-fantasy stories, but almost not Adventure Time. “Gumbaldia” and “Come Along With Me” (44-minute finale story) set up a final Ooo War between PBub and her insane Uncle/offspring, and halfway delivers on it. But then they ran out of plot, and were unwilling to go all the way and let the Candy Kingdoms nuke each other, so just added a new dumb monster for them to half-ass their way out of. BMO at the end of time with an almost empty world was interesting, and they failed utterly to deliver on it.

I loved classic Adventure Time, but the writers really got wound up too much in continuity and making sense of a senseless idea later on. It’s Thundarr on E, Mad Max with candy characters. That’s fun. A little “oh living in this vale of tears is kinda hard yo” goes a very long ways. Long plots ruin it.

★★★★★ for the single adventures, ★★★★☆ for the first serial, ★★★☆☆ for the second serial, ★★☆☆☆ for the finale.

WWDC 2020 Liveblogging

As posted on appdot.net:

Apparently I’m watching all of WWDC on my phone, because it’s the only current OS version device in my house, and of course a course table and video player only works with the absolute latest updates! F’shaw, like last year’s OS could handle a scrolling table?! Or video streams?!

Brings up George Floyd… but not . Some kind of fund for black developers is a good idea, but no details yet.

COVID, but nothing about the contact tracer or anything productive.

So now Craig.

“App Library” is like my page of folders auto-filled. With Apple Quality AI®, I’m sure. Probably not.

Widgets, OTOH, is a “finally!”, move usable widgets from the dashboard to pages.

PiP, great. Had that on my TV 40 years ago. Everyone except me hated me using it to channel-surf while waiting for ads to end.

Siri: 25 billion requests per month. 3B of those are me “set a timer for 3 minutes”.

Universal translator! That’s actually pretty cool. I was gonna snark, but if it’s even 75% accurate it’ll make phrasebooks obsolete.

Oh god Memoji. The hideous ingrown noses are super goddamned offensive to those of us with a real beak.

Ha ha maps and travel. As if. Just cancel this section until next year, guys. And by then, the Eugenics Wars or Terminator Uprising will have started. Won’t be no Paris to visit.

Car stuff, I don’t care. I replace a car every decade if that, I’m still using a tape adapter to play from my phone. And if I was getting a new car, I’m not a big enough asshole to get a Beemer.

OK, App Clips is like the Watch app-lets, but virally distributed by NFC or QR code. Not web tech or anything convenient.

Apple Pencil, remaking the Palm Pilot or Newton UI from the ’90s… today!

AirPods are not “magic”. They are bluetooth devices which can make me nauseous and vomit when the audio delay gets high or out of sync. I loathe this whole idea of wireless audio.

I’ve worn an Watch since launch, and it’s a great watch… All the stuff past time, calendar, timer, talking to Siri, kind of irrelevant to me.

Sleep tracking’s maybe a little judgy for me, I know I have erratic sleep and a machine’s not going to make it better.

“self-report” privacy report. So it’ll all be complete lies. You can’t trust marketing scum.

Home. Yeah, no, never letting a machine control my house. I barely trust light switches or the garage door remote.

What is this “Foundation” show? There’s a woman in it. There’s no women in Asimov’s Foundation! (OK, there’s 2 or 3 in the later books)

Why is it all dark and grim, cyan/orange tinted? It’s a book of conference room meetings.

Oh, fuck. “Entirely new design”. Big Sur? Seriously? I still think Weed was the best California name they should’ve used. Maybe Barstow if they wanted to go more Fear & Loathing.

“Buttons appear when you need them” = invisible mystery meat icons. Just what I never wanted.

They did the translucent menu bar back in Leopard? It was unusable.

And yeah, great, more shit moving into my menu bar, or a fake-Dashboard in Notifications. I liked the old Dashboard, one F-key or hot corner. 10+ years ago!

If I thought it’d be as reliable as Leopard, I’d be less wary.

Advanced new controls in Catalyst like checkboxes: Just like 2005!

Safari: Hey, the one mostly good product Apple ships. Let’s not fuck it up too much, guys! Kick Chrome for being a slow fat-ass while it’s down, that’s smart. I like that.

I just want my adblockers to block all the ads, guys. I don’t need fucking Yahoo! home page in Safari, I need the NY Times paywall to go fuck itself.

Recipe filter? What. Be serious.

Do I love tabs?
% safariCountTabs.applescript
Window #95 = 31 tabs – Window #99 = 5 tabs – Window #98 = 23 tabs – Window #97 = 26 tabs – Window #102 = 15 tabs – Window #103 = 14 tabs –

How’s your update gonna work with this madness? And I cleaned up last week! It was twice as much!

All right. The thing that matters.

“Transitioning to our own custom silicon”.

I guess “Fat Binary” is politically incorrect for fat-shaming, all-dancing, exercising Apple. So it’s “Universal Binary 2”.

And yes, of course they used the new hardware for the demos, that’s a good old Apple stunt.

Seems like it’s working full-speed. Which if it’s compiled for the device, it should be.

I’m more concerned with what happens to non-native apps? OK, “Rosetta 2”.

All right, what devices, how much, and how soon, Craigy?

Yes, yes, I played this shitty Tomb Raider reboot on the PS3. I care about code, not Lara’s pixelated ass. Nor about running iOS apps, I have a phone.

Hm. Dev kit? I’m still very negative on Swift, but maybe I’ll live (or find practical ways around that). If they’re gonna make good new hardware, and I do like many of the things in Big Sur. They just went from “no plan, last year’s tech, no future” to having a future.

Might be time to revise my plan, move my current iMac to Windows for games, use an ARM Mac for work and get back to shipping Mac/iOS stuff?

What I’m Watching: Ghidorah, the Three-Headed Monster

  • Ghidorah, the Three-Headed Monster (1964): Both UFO cultists and cops agree, heat wave in winter and meteor showers are weird. A cop is assigned to bodyguard a princess from a small island under civil war. Said princess is contacted by an alien voice and told to jump from the plane, and she never even got her drink! Scientists hike into the mountains to investigate a meteor landing.

I must say, Japan’s wilderness looks fantastic. The cinematography on this one, in color!, is head and shoulders above previous films. Even when they go into matte paintings and sets, it looks good. They do interesting cuts, like using a subway car as a wipe. It’s almost hard to believe this is Honda Ishiro still, not doing locked-down cameras and super simple cuts or wipes; earlier he was more a director of people and cool events, not using the camera well. Even the rear projections are now fairly close to seamless.

Naoko the journalist and the Princess are both cute as hell. Naoko’s cop brother is kind of a doofus, and utterly extraneous to the plot. The bodyguard cop has no personality except brooding and shooting (not very well, he never kills anyone with at least 30 shots), and there’s no love between him and the Princess in the first half; all he has is a picture, and she’s not herself. Has Honda learned cinematography, but forgotten about romance as the main driver of Human-scale plots?! What a terrible bargain.

The Mothra twins appear on TV, and summon a vision of the Mothra larva. This is a Japan that just lives with the regular existence of giant monsters and magic on TV, I don’t see how anyone can mock UFO cultists or prophets from Venus in that world.

“Stay out of Mount Aso, Rodan will emerge!” “Shut up prophet! … OH NO IT’S RODAN AAAIEEE!” Incredibly predictable scene, but perfect “fools die of their folly” scene. Rodan’s costume & flying puppet are much improved over the first movie, but it’s a little odd being more of a Pteranodon/Roc hybrid now.

“Don’t get on the ship!” And at least the important characters pay attention, but the poor sailors are going to meet… well, who else would be in the ocean? Big G’s moving eyes look really weird. The suit’s otherwise fine, but definitely reaching the end of this first design.

Fools stand far too close to Ghidorah’s… egg? Meteor? Spaceship? But someone must witness the birth of a death god. The Princess tells the protagonists the Earth is doomed, and sells it for once. We start to get a real kaiju cosmology here, with planets preyed on or defended by monsters.

Finally we have all the world’s monsters assembled, rampaging begins.

The assassins chasing the Princess thru the entire film have been unstoppable, but not very competent, and kind of a waste of time. The plot as it is would happen without them.

Possibly too much of the monster scenes are them arguing with Mothra, rather than fighting, there’s only a few minutes of King Ghidorah vs the three defending kaiju. There is a bit of destruction in Tokyo, but mostly it’s a beloved peasant village or wilderness at the foot of Mt Fuji. Mothra’s very slow and annoying power, Godzilla throwing rocks, Rodan standing around waving its wings, are enough to drive off the dragon. FOR NOW.

★★★½☆ – Needs about 15 minutes less Human time, replaced with monster fighting time.

This is a major influence on my favorite kaiju movie, GMK: Godzilla Mothra King Ghidorah Giant Monster All-Out Attack, but there Godzilla and Ghidorah switch places, and the subplots are wiped away so it’s just reporter, crazy old man as “prophet”, and monsters. And on the latest Hollywood Godzilla King of the Monsters, but there everything is 100x larger than life.

Flash End of Life

On the one hand, I’m glad Adobe took my advice from a decade ago to stop Flash, because it’s just a virus loader, produces the shittiest software possible, and is the anti-WWW. Their marketing zealots calling everyone else “whiners” because of their flaws has gone from eyeroll to falling on the floor laughing comedy.

On the other hand, a lot of stupid Flash games & animations are dead now.

What I’m Watching: Us

  • Us: Another Jordan Peele Twilight Zone flick. Text crawl claims that there’s thousands of miles of tunnels of mysterious purpose under America. With the implication that it’s full of monsters. So Dungeons & Dragons is real?! Good to know, Jordan. Then there’s 20+ minutes of utter boredom back in 1986, when normally I would rate the ’80s as the least boring part, very briefly a scene with some tension and the little girl Addy.

20 years later (and it feels like it), the plot starts. Addy’s very gentrified, possession-oriented black family settles into their Santa Cruz beach vacation house, get a boat, meet their honkie friend “Josh” and his blonde family at the beach. Nice and idyllic. And then out of nowhere, we get told more of the little girl’s scene, and the monsters show up.

Addy gets tied up and terrorized a lot, Dad is utterly useless, but the kids are fairly impressive little survivors.

As a slasher flick, there really aren’t enough victims, and it doesn’t sustain the tension, it keeps releasing to long “oh that’s over” scenes. The killers are more pathetic than terrifying.

SPOILER TIMES



















There’s a lot of weird visuals, which are poorly to never explained. The remake of Hands Across America (a USA For Africa charity event, you may know the song “We Are the World”) makes no sense, how did non-verbal shadows work this out? Police or soldiers will just destroy them once it’s sunlight. Do politicians have their own shadows, and how would scissor-wielding maniacs get past the Secret Service? The final scenes show helicopters flying over woods, presumably where the Shadows Across America line goes? Why aren’t they firing or dropping bombs on these known mass murderers?

Addy has a final descent into the mythic underworld by escalator (her knowing the way down telegraphed her origin, but it has problems, too), where she finds bunnies running loose (but no explanation how the killers raised them down there, or where all the supplies come from), and a long nonsense explanation about cloning and souls.

The duel/dance is passable, but Addy never cooperates with Red’s dance, which would’ve made this fight more interesting. I think especially of Jet Li’s The One, where he fights himself, but each has mastered a distinct martial arts style, so the fight’s visually amazing. This is… it reminds me of Marvel movies, where there’s amazing fight choreography but the actors aren’t all up to performing it, so you get a martial artist fighting a drunken bozo.

The final revelation about Addy doesn’t make a lot of sense. Addy’s awful vulnerable and emotional for a soulless murder machine like the others. Red’s croaky voice is from being strangled, fine, but why didn’t she ever come up to the surface before? How did she organize a worldwide cult of the shadows to come up at the same time, when they don’t talk, or really seem aware?

Obviously I’m pretty tolerant of implausible premises in movies, given my love of kaiju and fantasy, but this one falls apart internally worse than most.

★★★½☆ Good try, Jordan, better than your awful Twilight Zones, but not another “Get Out”. Jordan Peele is the new M. Night Shyamalan.

The concept’s been around a while: Mirror people, dopplegangers, or faerie changelings, ultimately going back to pre-historic myths. My favorite’s in the Nightbane RPG by Palladium Books, where the Nightland (always dark, mirror image Earth) is populated by dopplegangers of Earth people, just waiting for a chance to use a mirror as a portal and kill and replace you (Nightbane also borrows heavily from Clive Barker’s Cabal, Great and Secret Show, and Hellbound Heart). I really should dig the books up and run Nightbane again.